Inheritance dispute between siblings
Read the full caseShow less
The brother and sister came to the scheduled session together. The warmth between them prompted me to ask why they had come to me instead of simply talking things over at home or in a café. It quickly became clear that there were considerable tensions behind the sibling façade. They agreed that their parents’ house in eastern Holstein should be sold after their father’s death. But before the proceeds could be split in half, there were a few things to settle.
The brother reproached his sister for having spent two expensive years at a boarding school in England, while he had only attended the public school in Holstein. The sister, for her part, calculated the financial sacrifices she had made by visiting their father, who had dementia, more than once a month for six years and organizing his care on her own. Both siblings were good with numbers and presented me with complicated calculations meant to establish fairness. It was clear to me that these calculations would lead to a compromise only on the surface. So I offered them a second session.
The chance to let everything sink in was evidently just right. In the second session, I was able to shift the focus to the dynamics between the siblings. We talked about their different relationships with their mother, who had died earlier and whose death had hardly been discussed because of the worries about their father. Misunderstandings were cleared up and disappointments were voiced. Once again I turned the focus to the warmth between them that had been visible at the outset, which both saw as a great treasure now that their parents had died. In the end, the siblings agreed to set aside time for a personal conversation on the first weekend of every month; for the time being, they decided not to pursue the financial compensation they had calculated. Everything else, they said, was well on its way, and they would manage the rest on their own.

